My friend Trent gave me a pair of broken Logitech Harmony 659 remotes. I bought into the programmable universal remote ages ago when I purchased a Pronto TSU 2000 – a remote I still use regularly to drive my home theater. I’ve watched with interest the Harmony remotes become more popular and lower cost and have often encouraged people to consider getting them. Having a remote control that everyone in your family can understand how to use means better use of the audio / video system you have. I was really pleased to get these two remotes and figured I could fix both of them.
The first step is opening the remote. There are four screws indicated by the green circles in the picture at the top of this post. Two of the screws are inside the battery compartment. Then there are 6 tabs the clip the top and bottom together – indicated with blue circles. A putty knife and some gentle pressure should get the remote apart without any damage. For things like this it’s important to take your time and be persistent (but not too forceful).
I have two broken remotes. One has a non-responsive keyboard, the other has the USB connector busted off the circuit board. It would probably be fairly simple to combine the two into a single working remote, but that would be taking the easy way out. In the picture above you can see the broken off mini-USB connector. One of the pads has come off the circuit board entirely and the remainder have broken lose of the solder connections. I suspect this failure was a combination of a poor soldering job at the factory, and accidental use of extra force on the connector in normal use.
Prior to doing this repair I had not done any surface mount (SMD) soldering. I went to youtube to learn a few of the techniques for how to do this successfully. I wasn’t working quite at the same scale as is possible, but this was well beyond doing a single pin at a time. Basically the technique is to spread some flux, and drag a loaded soldering iron tip over the pins.
I’ve got a reasonably nice soldering iron now, but I lacked many of the other useful tools such as a a flux pen or loupe. I did have handy some flux I’ve used for soldering copper pipe and a toothpick to apply it with. It worked fine – but don’t do as I did. It turns out that “Kester SP-30 is too corrosive for electrical or electronics soldering applications“. Ok, well lesson learned about making do – I’ll have to see what I can do about cleaning any residual flux off the board.
Above you’ll see the result of my first attempt. From a distance it appears to be all good. However, with a bright LED flashlight and my digital camera with 20x optical zoom told a different story.
Close, but not quite. There is some visible bridging of the solder between the pins. So clearly this wasn’t going to work and I needed to start over.
I used some solder wick to remove the old solder. This is a fine copper braid that you heat up in contact with the solder and it sucks up the solder and leaves a clean connection. I should have done this from the start – cleaning off all of the old solder. The result was nice clean solder pads ready for another try.
This time no bridging, just enough solder to get a contact and no more. It’s not as pretty as I’d like it to have been but it appears to work just fine. While this was a bit finicky, it wasn’t really that hard to do. I’ll be a lot braver about dealing with SMD parts in the future.
Initially I had some problems getting it to appear under Linux. I was able to A/B test the other broken unit (bad keypad) as it has a working USB port (very nice to have more than one to do comparisons with). So I started thinking that maybe there was a problem with my soldering work after all. Then I found some instructions on getting the remote into “safe mode”: With no batteries installed, hold the OFF button, plug in USB connection to computer. Once I did this, the remote did show up just fine under Linux. The only weird thing was that after the one time, it showed up even when I didn’t invoke “safe mode” – maybe that caused something to get reset? Before you think your Harmony is broken, try “safe mode” – it might just fix things for you.
I did flip over to Windows XP to run the Harmony software to actually program the remote. Later I may experiment with the Linux solution for working with the Harmony remotes.
Excellent. Glad at least one is working now… Only one clarification required:
“accidental use of extra force on the connector in normal use” was not exactly right… unless you define “repeated abuse from small child” as normal use!
Great SMT soldering comic http://www.siliconfarmers.com/smtmanga/
Good write up, thanks. I have a 620, and the same mini-USB port broke off as well. Remote lasted about 7 years, so that is a pretty good run. But, considering that I only synced the remote about twice a year, it is pretty poor quality for the mini-usb port to fail after less than 50 uses. Dropping the remove over the years may have contributed to this.
I am going to try to find someone local who is better at soldering that me, and see if they can repair/reattach the mini-usb port to the circuit board.