Roo's View – Page 75 – A clever tagline should go here

Time Machine and Linux

Hard Drive - 2 Flash/Brolly by geerlingguy, on Flickr

Previously I had written about using an Ubuntu server to host Apple Time Machine backups. Now that I’ve retired the old server, I needed to re-do some of that work to get backups running again. This time I decided to skip Part A – which was about enabling AFP to make it as Mac friendly as possible. My new setup simply uses Samba to expose the previously created time machine volume as described in Part B of my old post. This seems to be working just fine.

I learned the backup lesson the hard way, losing a 20Gig drive a few years ago. There are in my office two dis-assembled hard drives: one which is the failed drive, and the second was a working same model number drive I bought on eBay. The plan was to swap the controller board to hopefully save some of the data (it was my old web server). It turns out that even though the drive models were the same, the internals were different – one drive had a single platter, the other a dual platter. If this blog posting gives you that “yeah, I should really get my backup story sorted out” feeling, then go do something about it right now. Hindsight is 20/20.

I meant to take a picture of that pair of drives to accompany this post, but failed to get a quick picture before I left the office. I figured that I’d use the Creative Commons material from Flickr for this post. It turns out that giving the correct attribution to the photo is a bit of a pain via Flickr (they should really fix that) – but there is a solution: www.ImageCodr.org. With a few clicks and a cut and paste from the Flickr photo you want to use, you get an HTML snippet to use.

I had been using rsync to do backups on my old server, backing up from the main drive to one of the data drives. As well, a number of the machines around the house would rsync backup over the network to the server. On my new server I’m using rsnapshot, which is based on rsync but provides some nice scripting to give you a nice set of default behaviours. Setting it up to do local backups from the server main drive to a mounted data drive was trivial.

Using rsync you can configure incremental backups – utilizing hard links to provide multiple full directory trees, with only a small increase in disk footprint. Rsnapshot uses this facility to provide hourly, daily, and weekly backups – very similar to Time Machine’s backup story which as the data gets older, you get less granularity. I’ve set it up with daily, hourly and monthly backups – after a few weeks it looks like this:
drwxr-xr-x 3 root root 4096 2009-04-21 00:30 daily.0 drwxr-xr-x 3 root root 4096 2009-04-20 00:31 daily.1 drwxr-xr-x 3 root root 4096 2009-04-19 00:30 daily.2 drwxr-xr-x 3 root root 4096 2009-04-18 00:31 daily.3 drwxr-xr-x 3 root root 4096 2009-04-17 00:31 daily.4 drwxr-xr-x 3 root root 4096 2009-04-16 00:30 daily.5 drwxr-xr-x 3 root root 4096 2009-04-15 00:30 daily.6 drwxr-xr-x 3 root root 4096 2009-04-14 00:30 weekly.0 drwxr-xr-x 3 root root 4096 2009-04-07 00:30 weekly.1

So while I’ve got many full file trees, through the use of hardlinks only 4.7Gig of storage is being used to have 9 copies of a 3.7Gig file tree.

Reading Material

I read regularly – aside from spending countless hours in front of a computer screen I also like to sit down with a book. My collection is pretty heavily skewed towards speculative fiction. Similar to my DVD collection which I re-watch, I like to re-read books. Some of the classics (Dune) I’ll read every couple of years, most go longer between reads – but there is hardly a book in my collection I haven’t read twice.

This year I’ve read a lot of Neal Stephenson’s work – having finally got my hands on the last two books in the Baroque Cycle, I re-read Quicksilver and worked my way through the whole series. If you haven’t read any Neal Stephenson, start with Snow Crash. Lots of his more recent work is more of a slog through, and the style won’t suit everyone – I personally enjoy it, but it does take a few hundred pages to get into. I very recently finished Anathem – again, not for everyone, but I thought it was a great read.

There have also been a few eBooks I’ve read through. I still really like having a physical book, so the eBooks I’ve read have been free ones – but there are some good free books out there, and its possibly going to get me hooked on eBooks.

Little Brother – Cory Doctorow
Very entertaining. I read Eastern Standard Tribe (physical book) and wasn’t as impressed.
The Hacker Crackdown – Bruce Sterling
I may have read this when it came out, but its referenced by Little Brother and a neat companion read.
OVERCLOCKED – Cory Doctorow
Some short stories, and like all of Cory Doctorow’s work is available free. (Yes, you can also buy his books from bookstores)
Hal Spacejock – Simon Haynes
This is the first in a series, I’m only part way through it – fun so far. The rest of the series is non-free.
Fallen Angels – Jerry Pournelle, Larry Niven and Michael Flynn
I haven’t gotten to this one, but with these authors I’m sure to enjoy it. This one comes from the Baen Free Library which has many more titles.

I’ve been reading these on my NDS using dslibris. Using OpenOffice.org to export to xhtml, I did have a problem with the export but found this helpful explaination that lead to the fix. I did already have a java runtime installed, but OpenOffice.org needed to be configured to know about it.

Books are sort of like software, eBooks more so. It is interesting to see what has happened to music through the digital revolution (mp3’s), and now we’re starting to see TV and Movies go through the same transformation. What happens when matter assemblers become available? Suddenly even physical objects will be trivial to replicate – once the cost gets driven down, what then? Time to go read some fiction..

The New Server

I had previously posted about the server than runs lowtek.ca and that it had been given me trouble. Well, the new parts came pretty quickly and it was a good thing – as just last week the old server packed it in. It turns out that the most likely reason for the instability was the CPU fan, as it totally seized on the failure day and my CPU temperature climbed up past 90C. An $8 fan might have solved my immediate problem, and been a lot less headache — having temperature graphs of the server would have helped spot this, something I plan to do with the new one.

At least I had a good excuse to buy new hardware. So here is a picture of it hanging out in my furnace room next to the water heater. While the new system is based on a MiniITX mainboard, I’ve opted to use a full size ATX tower case to house it (the case was a free hand me down from a friend).

I did modify the case quite heavily. The stock fan grills were simply holes drilled in the case – it was more grill than not, so the airflow was pretty poor. A couple of minutes with the dremel removed the grills entirely. I also opened up the front bezel to provide easy inflow of air for the lower case fan. The upper case fan is mounted to a pair of drive bay covers I’ve glued together.

This case has 6 x 5.25 drive bays, and 3×3.5 bays. My system drive lives down in the bottom and the data drives are up where the top fan is.

I also cut a fan vent in the side panel to blow down onto the mainboard itself. This I did with a jigsaw, and I think it turned out well considering it was my first attempt a something like this.

This older ATX tower case had all of the right connections for this new motherboard. Power, reset and HDD connectors hooked up no problem. The power LED was a 3 pin connector vs. the required 2 pin connector. Karl was able to hook me up with a spare HDD connector that I spliced onto the power LED.

Since there were mounting locations for 2 more exhaust fans, I couldn’t help myself and added two more at the top/back of the case.

If we count fans, I’ve got 5 case fans, 1 more in the power supply, and a chipset fan on the mainboard. Overkill? Yes. Required? No, probably not. There seem to be plenty of folk out there running exactly the same board with very minimal cooling.

My motivation here was the current system failing due to heat death, and I’d like this new system to run problem free for years. The extra cost of a few fans isn’t a big deal, and its very quiet relative to the furnace. I may further duct / optimize the cooling as the measurements thus far don’t show much of a delta from other peoples numbers on the net.

One more picture of the guts, to give you a sense of how small the MiniITX board is:

The transition from the old system to the new one should have been as simple as dropping in the drives and booting. Unfortunately the old version of Ubuntu (Dapper) didn’t have support for the new Atom board and couldn’t make use of its network drivers etc.

Worse still, the system drive refused to boot in the new machine. It is something that still has me scratching my head. I even went to the effort of cloning the boot drive onto another which I had proven would boot with the new system – and still no go. It was almost as if the MBR was in an unexpected location. Last week I lost a bunch of sleep.

Above is a picture of the old server while it was cloning the boot drive (which as I mentioned, turned out to be a waste of time). After five hours of beating my head on the problem, I simply moved the data drives to the new system – and did a clean install on a fresh boot drive. The old server continued to host lowtek.ca on the old system drive using the external fan to keep the CPU cool.

Yesterday I turned off the old server. Here are a few URLs that I found helpful in the migration:

As I host a number of wordpress blogs here migrating them required a database backup / restore. I simply copied over the /var/www directory data instead of re-installing the blog software itself.

Backup:

mysqldump --add-drop-table -h localhost -u sql_username \ --password=sql_passwd sql_database_name > blog.bak.sql

Create DB on new host:

$ mysql -u root -p

mysql> CREATE DATABASE sql_database_name;

mysql> GRANT ALL PRIVILEGES ON sql_database_name.* TO “sql_username”@”localhost”
-> IDENTIFIED BY “sql_passwd”;

mysql> FLUSH PRIVILEGES;

mysql> exit

Restore:

mysql -h localhost -u sql_username -p sql_database_name < blog.bak.sql

Well, if you’re still hanging in there – let’s talk about power consumption. I borrowed Trent’s Kill-A-Watt meter and did some measuring. My home desktop machine draws around 150Watts, and up to 200Watts of power when loaded (and using the CD drive). The old server machine used 2W in standby, 120W during boot (loaded) and 112W steady state. The new machine uses 1W in standby, a peak of 100W at boot (when the drives are spinning up), and 60W steady state.

In conclusion: Server machines need to have monitoring setup to track potential problems (temperature). Migration of your data is less painful if you keep an install log with notes and links (thank goodness I did one last time). New hardware usually needs a new software install, don’t fight it.